Mastering Email Metrics for Fundraising Campaigns: A Deep Dive into Open Rates, CTR, and CTOR

In partnership with

Email marketing has become an indispensable tool in fundraising campaigns. Whether you’re targeting investors, donors, or supporters, understanding and optimizing your email metrics can significantly impact your results. You can refine your approach and maximize engagement by analyzing key metrics like open rates, click-through rates (CTR), and click-to-open rates (CTOR).

However, one of the biggest challenges for marketers and fundraisers, especially those starting, is determining what qualifies as “good” performance. What benchmarks should you use? How do your results compare to industry standards? This comprehensive guide will help you decode email metrics and apply insights to your fundraising efforts.

The Importance of Email Metrics in Fundraising

Tracking email metrics allows you to understand what resonates with your audience, identify areas for improvement, and measure the effectiveness of your campaigns. For fundraising specifically, these insights can guide critical adjustments, such as refining subject lines, improving email content, or testing call-to-action placements.

Metrics are not just numbers; they tell a story. Open rates reveal how well you’re grabbing attention. CTR shows how engaging your email content is. CTOR gives a deeper look into the effectiveness of your messaging. Together, these metrics provide a roadmap for improving your fundraising campaigns.

Key Metrics to Track

Let’s break down the essential metrics for fundraising emails, how to calculate them, and what benchmarks to aim for.

1. Open Rate: The Gateway Metric

Definition:
Open rate measures the percentage of recipients who open your email. It’s a critical first step in gauging your email’s performance since no other metric matters if your audience isn’t opening your emails.

Why It Matters for Fundraising:
Open rates reflect the strength of your subject lines, sender reputation, and timing. A high open rate suggests that your audience finds your emails relevant and enticing, essential for capturing initial attention in a competitive inbox.

Most email platforms automatically calculate this for you.

What’s a Good Open Rate?

• Average open rate: 21.5% (across all industries in 2021)

• Fundraising benchmarks: Open rates often fall in line with nonprofit averages, typically 26.6%.

Tips to Improve Open Rates:

1. Write compelling subject lines: Use urgency, personalization, or questions to grab attention.

2. Segment your list: Tailor content to specific donor segments for higher relevance.

3. Test send times: Experiment with different days and times to identify when your audience is most active.

2. Click-Through Rate (CTR): Measuring Engagement

Definition:
CTR is the percentage of recipients who click on a link or call-to-action (CTA) in your email. It shows how effectively your content drives readers to take action.

Why It Matters for Fundraising:
CTR reveals whether your email content is persuasive enough to inspire engagement, such as donating, registering for an event, or reading more about your campaign.

What’s a Good CTR?

• Average CTR: 2.3% (across all industries in 2021).

• Fundraising benchmarks: Nonprofit CTR averages hover around 2.7%.

Tips to Improve CTR:

1. Craft compelling CTAs: Use action-oriented language like “Donate Now” or “Learn More.”

2. Optimize link placement: Ensure links are prominent and naturally integrated into your content.

3. Include visual elements: Buttons or images can draw attention to CTAs.

4. A/B test content: Experiment with different headlines, images, and layouts to identify what drives clicks.

3. Click-to-Open Rate (CTOR): The Content Effectiveness Metric

Definition:
CTOR measures the percentage of recipients who clicked on a link after opening your email. Unlike CTR, which considers all delivered emails, CTOR focuses solely on engaged recipients who opened the email.

Why It Matters for Fundraising:
CTOR provides insight into how well your email content resonates with your audience. It helps you refine copy, visuals, and layout to make your emails more engaging.

What’s a Good CTOR?

• Average CTOR: 10.5% (across all industries in 2021).

• Fundraising benchmarks: Nonprofit CTOR averages around 10.2%.

Tips to Improve CTOR:

1. Focus on quality content: Ensure your copy is clear, concise, and aligns with your audience’s interests.

2. Use engaging visuals: Images, infographics, and videos can boost interaction.

3. Personalize your messaging: Address recipients by name and tailor content based on past interactions.

Industry Benchmarks for Fundraising Emails

Understanding industry benchmarks helps you gauge your performance and set realistic goals. Below are average open rates, CTRs, and CTORs for nonprofits and related industries:

Use these benchmarks as a starting point, but aim to establish your internal benchmarks based on past performance.

Advanced Strategies for Tracking and Improving Email Metrics

1. Segmentation for Personalization

Segmenting your email list allows you to send highly targeted messages. For example:

• Separate past donors from potential donors and tailor content accordingly.

• Segment based on donation amounts or frequency to send personalized appeals.

2. A/B Testing

A/B testing involves experimenting with one variable at a time (e.g., subject line, CTA, or image). Use A/B testing to:

• Compare two different subject lines to see which drives higher open rates.

• Test CTA phrasing to identify what prompts the most clicks.

3. Automating Follow-Ups

Set up automated email workflows to nurture relationships. For instance:

• Send a thank-you email immediately after a donation.

• Follow up with impact stories to show donors the tangible results of their contributions.

4. Monitor Email Deliverability

Poor deliverability can skew your metrics. Use tools to monitor bounce rates, unsubscribe rates, and spam complaints.

Real-Life Application: Improving Fundraising Campaigns

Case Study 1: Boosting Open Rates with Better Timing

A nonprofit organization noticed that their open rates were below the industry average. Analyzing their audience data revealed that most recipients were active on weekday mornings. After adjusting their send times, their open rate increased from 18% to 27%.

Case Study 2: Increasing CTR with Personalized CTAs

A charity tested two versions of their fundraising email. The first had a generic CTA (“Donate Now”), while the second personalized the ask based on donation history (“Help Us Reach $10,000”). The personalized email achieved a 3.8% CTR, compared to 2.1% for the generic version.

Case Study 3: Improving CTOR with Interactive Content

A wildlife conservation organization added a short quiz about endangered species to their email. The CTOR jumped from 8% to 15%, as recipients engaged with the interactive content.

Key Takeaways for Fundraising Success

1. Track the Right Metrics: Monitor open rates, CTR, and CTOR to gain a full picture of your email performance.

2. Compare to Benchmarks: Use industry standards to set goals but establish your internal benchmarks for the most accurate insights.

3. Continuously Optimize: Regularly test and refine your subject lines, content, and CTAs.

4. Leverage Segmentation and Personalization: Tailor your messaging to audience segments for higher engagement.

5. Focus on Deliverability: Ensure your emails reach your audience by maintaining a healthy sender reputation.

By mastering email metrics and applying these insights, you can elevate your fundraising campaigns, engage your audience more effectively, and achieve your goals more precisely. Remember, every click, open, and engagement brings you closer to building lasting relationships with your supporters.

Your daily AI dose

Mindstream is your one-stop shop for all things AI.

How good are we? Well, we become only the second ever newsletter (after the Hustle) to be acquired by HubSpot. Our small team of writers works hard to put out the most enjoyable and informative newsletter on AI around.

It’s completely free, and you’ll get a bunch of free AI resources when you subscribe.

Click here to subscribe